@aristotles_id wrote:In theory, the buyer should escalate the claim, as selller you are not really in a position to assess the damage, but like may things ebay, it is in practice a real mess. That business with the conflicting dates is typical.
So I have some great news - ebay has refunded the buyer, both not requiring them to send the product back and not requiring me to pay for the loss since they agreed it was damaged in transit. And I also recieved a notice that I will not recieve any defects.
I waited until after the 21st as the instructions above indicated. After I returned to the page on the 21st there was a new option to "Ask ebay to step in and help".
I did consider asking the buyer to escalate it, but decided to do it myself to move things along faster instead of delaying the case further.
The strange thing about the escalate to ebay option is they make you pick a reason why you couldn't solve the problem yourself, but they are all things like "buyer didn't return item" or "couldn't work out problems with buyer".
The reason "damanaged in transit" is not on the list , but I just picked "couldn't work things out with the buyer", and then in the comments I put something like "The buyer and I both agreed the product appeared to be damaged in transit after the GSP recieved it.
The buyer reported the package was heavily beaten up, and the device had a brand new drive that was heavily tested prior to shipping, and likely the only way it would have stopped working was handled too roughly, and the condition of the packaging supports that. So i'm escalating so the buyer can be refunded by the GSP program"
Anyways a day after escalating with that, they agreed to refund the buyer in full under the GSP.
I do have to say even though this was a positive experience I am a little worried about using the GSP now since i've just recieved another message that another gsp order has been "delayed" for inspection just like this case did.. So i'm a little scared this new order might end up damanged too if getting held by inspection means extra rough handling. We will see how it goes this time :).
Thanks again everyone for your help - and hope this helps someone else manage their future "damanged in transit" claims.